Letter to the Editor in Response to Globe Editorial on SDP Legislation

The Boston Globe on May 28th editorialized in favor of Governor Baker’s recently filed legislation to revamp Massachusetts “Sexually Dangerous Persons” statute. The legislation was filed, in part, in response to the Supreme Judicial Court’s decision in the case of Wayne Chapman. The editorial can be seen here: Sex Offender Bill Targets Child Predators – Boston Globe Article May 28 2019:

A Letter to the Editor was submitted in response to the Editorial on June 3rd; it has not yet been printed so it is unlikely to be at this point, so we wanted to share it.

The Globe’s editorial suggesting the Legislature has failed to protect the public from pedophiles is unsupported, uninformed, and ill-advised.  Governor Baker’s proposed legislation is a solution looking for a problem.

The legislative scheme that incarcerated Wayne Chapman for decades, even after he completed a thirty-year prison sentence, is calibrated to comport with constitutional protections.  In “Sexually Dangerous Persons” proceedings, we incarcerate people indefinitely based on predictions about future behavior.  For some, this means a lifetime commitment.  Others, like Chapman, remain incarcerated until they are too old and debilitated to reoffend.  Others receive treatment and are now living in our communities offense-free.   Last year, this paper reported that Qualified Examiners discharged 49 people from civil commitment between 2015 and 2017.  Only one has returned to prison — for allegedly stealing a motor vehicle.  This is a system that is working.

The Supreme Judicial Court recognizes the delicate balance between public safety and the deterioration of civil liberties posed by civil commitments.  We urge our leaders to refrain from instituting costly, unnecessary, and unconstitutional legislation, and hope this paper resists fear mongering about a threat to public safety that does not exist.

Respectfully submitted,
Randy Gioia, Deputy Chief of the Public Defender Division
Vanessa Velez, Deputy Chief of the Private Counsel Division
Mark Larsen, Director of the Mental Health Litigation Department